1. #1
    Ducked in here to avoid the paparazzi Has every David Cassidy record!
    Join Date Jan 2012
    Posts 20
    Rep Power 36

    Default What legislation would bring online piracy to an end?

    Hi
    I have been listening to your radio show archives and it has been a really positive experience.
    On a personal level I think I really needed to hear a bunch of guys who really care about music, taking about music and how important it is to them.

    On listening to the shows you have really brought home the effect of piracy i.e. you have personalised it. I now have a bunch of people in my head that I know this really makes a difference to and can see how that difference has a serious knock on effect on the music we hear, where its recorded etc etc.

    It is strange as these things are kind of obvious but hearing real people who it makes a real difference to, makes me care more and helps for me to then rethink my position on things and actually get behind something to lesson the problem.

    So what legislation do you feel will stop or dramatically lesson online piracy? How does the line between the freedom the internet offers and the consequences of that freedom cause get drawn?

    If it is true as I heard on your show that only 1% of music downloads are paid for then how should that be stopped/lessoned.

    For example the legislation on the internet that recently tried to be passed through the US and Europe was met with widespread condemnation from wikipedia etc. for removing freedom from the internet etc. Were you for this or against this? Would it make a difference to music piracy?

    I always hear the arguments from my friends that large corporations/governments just want to control the internet for their own selfish ends, however if that means that there is a return to music being bought then yes thats good for large media conglomerates but also everyone else beneath them wanting to still have a job and get paid etc.

    So what legislation would you support to decrease online piracy?
    Do you think its coming anytime soon?
    If/when it arrives do you think there will be a recapitalisation of your area of the industry?

    Geoff
  2. #2
    Join Date Nov 2006
    Posts 6,786
    Rep Power 2500000000

    Default Re: What legislation would bring online piracy to an end?

    It's not a question of legislation, The laws we already have are FIRMLY on "our" side.

    It's a social engineering matter. Technology has opened a new avenue for social interaction, and the social norms and common practice boundaries for that have to be established.

    new laws will NOT "solve" the problem. Applying more laws to piracy is just "squeezing the ballon."
    "...but ma, audio engineering IS gainful employment!..."

    "...If I wuz at that club where Miles played one note I would have bounced ONE BOTTLE off his shiny fucking coconut. What? He's Phil Glass now?..." -Slipperman

    "...never attribute to magic, that which can be explained by conspiracy."
  3. #3
    Join Date Sep 2009
    Location Quake City
    Posts 10,272
    Rep Power 379012223

    Default Re: What legislation would bring online piracy to an end?

    I disagree, somewhat, anyway.

    We do have plenty of laws in place in they were properly enforced, but there are a couple of key areas where more is needed.

    First, the "safe harbor" provision of the DMCA needs to be fixed to prevent businesses profiting from facilitating piracy and pulling a Bart Simpson "I didn't do it!" routine.

    Second, we NEED blocking of offshore infringing sites. Infringing sites within the country should be able to be controlled without much more than the DMCA fix, but offshore sites are another matter.

    Interestingly, the UK has recently instructed all their major ISPs to block The Pirate Bay. It should be interesting to see the effect this has on both piracy and sales over the next months - I'm betting it will be significant and if so should point the way for actions within the US.

    Incidentally, the protests that killed SOPA were a well planned and executed attack by Google, which spent more money on lobbying against SOPA than they did total in the previous few years - and that's just the legal lobbying, not the behind the scenes influence peddling they're so good at.
    Last edited by John Eppstein; May 8th, 2012 at 12:31 AM.
    Originally Posted by Bob Ohlsson
    Everything is some mixture of awesome and suck. We simply want the awesome to be highlighted sufficiently that it distracts listeners from the suck.
    Originally Posted by Bob Ohlsson
    The appropriate role for science is the study of observed phenomena to gain an understanding. It is not dictating what people ought or ought not to be observing.
    Hey, if I'm Grumpy, where the hell is Snow White????
  4. #4
    Ducked in here to avoid the paparazzi Has every David Cassidy record!
    Join Date Jan 2012
    Posts 20
    Rep Power 36

    Default Re: What legislation would bring online piracy to an end?

    "Second, we NEED blocking of offshore infringing sites. Infrionging sites within the country should be able to be controlled without much more than the DMCA fix, but offshore sites are another matter."

    Seems to be the right idea and given the loss of revenue and therefore tax revenue I am surprised this isn't happening more, but then I understand very little about why piracy is allowed to go on unchallenged on the internet.

    "Incidentally, the protests that killed SOPA were a well planned and executed attack by Google,"

    excuse my ignorance but why, what does google stand to lose?

    This is a separate issue but I know mixerman mentioned his son listens to music on youtube, all young people I know listen to music on youtube I even find myself doing it these days. It seems strange to me that thats happening why give all your stuff away?

    Geoff

    Bought Ben Hudsons new track BIGkids - Superhero today love it
  5. #5
    Join Date Mar 2007
    Location Gothenburg, Sweden
    Posts 1,174
    Rep Power 536871043

    Default Re: What legislation would bring online piracy to an end?

    making people responsible acording to local, "physical", laws is a step I'd love to see more of...
  6. #6
    Join Date Sep 2009
    Location Quake City
    Posts 10,272
    Rep Power 379012223

    Default Re: What legislation would bring online piracy to an end?

    "Incidentally, the protests that killed SOPA were a well planned and executed attack by Google,"

    excuse my ignorance but why, what does google stand to lose?
    Google stands to lose a lot - they make millions and millions of dollars placing advertising on pirate sites to start with.

    They also have taken an adversary stance to copyright in general and enforcement of copyright law in particular. It's part of Google's mission statement that they want to compile all IP and make it available for free - obviously they can't do that if they have to pay royalties, so any enemy of copyright is a friend of Google. (Of course they don't feel the same way about publishing their own IP, just that belonging to everyone else.)


    This is a separate issue but I know mixerman mentioned his son listens to music on youtube, all young people I know listen to music on youtube I even find myself doing it these days. It seems strange to me that thats happening why give all your stuff away?

    Geoff
    Youtube is now placing ads on most of their stuff and splitting the revenue with rights holders.

    Also, presumably those who actually CARE about what they listen to will use YT for discovery and then purchase what they like in a format that offers better quality.

    making people responsible acording to local, "physical", laws is a step I'd love to see more of...
    I'd like to see some international treaty action start happening. There have been some moves in the right direction but we need more.
    Originally Posted by Bob Ohlsson
    Everything is some mixture of awesome and suck. We simply want the awesome to be highlighted sufficiently that it distracts listeners from the suck.
    Originally Posted by Bob Ohlsson
    The appropriate role for science is the study of observed phenomena to gain an understanding. It is not dictating what people ought or ought not to be observing.
    Hey, if I'm Grumpy, where the hell is Snow White????
  7. #7
    Join Date Sep 2007
    Location East Glenbeckistan
    Posts 3,790
    Rep Power 536871124

    Default Re: What legislation would bring online piracy to an end?

    If you think that piracy of music and movies is bad, Google is in trouble for knowingly selling ads to parties involved in human trafficking and the 3rd world sex slave trade. Google also got busted for selling ads to parties who vend controlled substances. This offense cost Google's INVESTORS a whopping half-billion dollars. What should have happened is Schmidt and Company should have sat time being some bubba's prison bitch.
    "Far too many people suffer from the anal-cranial inversion. They got their heads stuck up their asses!" - Tom Dowd
    "A great, timeless album is more than just an entertainment app." - Don Was
    "Success does not mean success. You are only as successful as your last hit record." - Patrick Adams (record producer)
    "The tech sector is like a guy in a crowded prison cell, who finds a hand grenade, and sets it off, so that he'll have the entire cell to himself." - Dwoz
  8. #8
    Join Date Sep 2007
    Location East Glenbeckistan
    Posts 3,790
    Rep Power 536871124

    Default Re: What legislation would bring online piracy to an end?

    OH! And the next time I get photographed by the Google street-view cam I'm calling the cops and suing Google for harassment!
    "Far too many people suffer from the anal-cranial inversion. They got their heads stuck up their asses!" - Tom Dowd
    "A great, timeless album is more than just an entertainment app." - Don Was
    "Success does not mean success. You are only as successful as your last hit record." - Patrick Adams (record producer)
    "The tech sector is like a guy in a crowded prison cell, who finds a hand grenade, and sets it off, so that he'll have the entire cell to himself." - Dwoz
  9. #9
    Ducked in here to avoid the paparazzi Has every David Cassidy record!
    Join Date Jan 2012
    Posts 20
    Rep Power 36

    Default Re: What legislation would bring online piracy to an end?

    I never realised google placed ads on people sites I always assumed people put them there themselves, shows how little I understand.

    The human trafficking case if true is obviously horrendous.

    So is googles lobbying power such that it dwarfs that of the media industries i.e groups like the Vivendi group which own universal etc. I suppose it must be.

    I am surprised that when SOPA bill was being debated there wasn't a greater push from the media to gain public support etc.

    I will go and read more about it.
    Thanks
    Geoff
  10. #10
    Join Date Sep 2007
    Location East Glenbeckistan
    Posts 3,790
    Rep Power 536871124

    Default Re: What legislation would bring online piracy to an end?

    The human trafficking case if true is obviously horrendous.
    UPDATE: Reps. Blackburn and Maloney, and Human Rights Advocates Call on Google to Stop Profiting from Human Trafficking Advertising - http://musictechpolicy.wordpress.com/2012/04/05/here-we-go-again-human-rights-advocates-call-on-google-to-stop-profiting-from-human-trafficking-advertising/

    Chris Castle is our eye on Google. I suggest subscribing to his blog.

    So is googles lobbying power such that it dwarfs that of the media industries i.e groups like the Vivendi group which own universal etc. I suppose it must be.
    The way many of the so-called "tech companies" got where they are is by using other people's venture cash and stock portfolio investment money to prop up their bottom lines, then use that cash to buy out real companies, often times with disastrous results. The AOL buyout of Time-Warner followed by the combined AOLTime-Warner crashing into the ground like a flaming jetliner due to AOL's people's mismanagement of the combined company is the classic example. Lots of people get screwed, the whole way from the individual investor who looses his retirement savings to the grunt-level employee who is out of a job.

    So yes Google has lots and lots and lots of cash on their balance sheet but it is anyone's guess how much of that money is actual profit earned on income verses raising venture capital and selling stock shares to the general public. My bet it is the later and eventually Google will be exposed as a ponzi scheme and implode like Enron did once the average investor and/or the SEC comes to the realization as to how over valued Google likely is.

    I am surprised that when SOPA bill was being debated there wasn't a greater push from the media to gain public support etc.
    There was/is a huge push from a variety of industries outside of entertainment who support SOPA including the major pharmaceutical companies. What I find so totally shocking is that Google has more influence in the halls of congress than Merck, Pfizer, Glaxo/Smith/Kline, Schering/Plough, Lilly, J&J, Bristol-Myers Squibb, and Abbott combined. There is something radically wrong with this because in the real world Google can NOT be bigger than the whole pharma industry. And remember, Google is by no means the only company of it's type that opposes SOPA. Just the biggest.
    "Far too many people suffer from the anal-cranial inversion. They got their heads stuck up their asses!" - Tom Dowd
    "A great, timeless album is more than just an entertainment app." - Don Was
    "Success does not mean success. You are only as successful as your last hit record." - Patrick Adams (record producer)
    "The tech sector is like a guy in a crowded prison cell, who finds a hand grenade, and sets it off, so that he'll have the entire cell to himself." - Dwoz
  11. #11
    once played a seventh chord in a folk song Saw Yentle 46 times
    Join Date Dec 2006
    Location Where all yer dreams come true
    Posts 194
    Rep Power 528060848

    Default Re: What legislation would bring online piracy to an end?

    352355]
    I am surprised that when SOPA bill was being debated there wasn't a greater push from the media to gain public support etc.
    [/QUOTE]

    I'm not. Lars Ulrich Syndrome.

    Obviously Metallica is still doing just fine 12 years after that, but it did give them an unfavorable view from the public for a short time (remember that viral video of cartoon Hetfield growling "NAPSTER BAD! MONEY GOOD!"?)

    There's really no nice way to ask someone "would you please stop ripping me off?" You will either get a denial that you are being ripped off or angry denunciations like "well you're so rich and greedy I'm entitled to rip you off. Music is for the PEOPLE."

    I just saw a recent quote from Blackie Lawless of WASP, who was himself paraphrasing Perry Farrell, saying that people are complaining there's no good new music, but it's because of those people stealing the music and putting the labels out of business, so they shouldn't really complain. That was a defense of anti-piracy that really rang true to me.
  12. #12
    Plays in Winger cover band Born To Be Mild!
    Join Date Jul 2011
    Location Wellington NZ
    Posts 720
    Rep Power 469762099

    Default Re: What legislation would bring online piracy to an end?

    ... Chris Castle is our eye on Google. I suggest subscribing to his blog. ...
    Just be aware that he's as biased and agenda-ridden as Mike Masnick (Techdirt), but in the opposite direction.
  13. #13
    Plays in Winger cover band Born To Be Mild!
    Join Date Jul 2011
    Location Wellington NZ
    Posts 720
    Rep Power 469762099

    Default Re: What legislation would bring online piracy to an end?

    ... I'd like to see some international treaty action start happening. There have been some moves in the right direction but we need more.
    Not if we can help it...
    http://www.stuff.co.nz/business/6883...NZ-legislation

    (The TPPA contains some swingeing copyright provisions.)
  14. #14
    Join Date Nov 2006
    Location Long Island, NY, USA
    Posts 9,900
    Rep Power 536871339

    Default Re: What legislation would bring online piracy to an end?

    Not if we can help it...
    http://www.stuff.co.nz/business/6883...NZ-legislation

    (The TPPA contains some swingeing copyright provisions.)
    Tobacco companies' arguments that the US Government's proposal to display graphic health warnings on cigarette packets abridges their freedom of speech are being fought in the US courts and are likely to reach the Supreme Court soon.
    That's the only example cited in that article, if you've read it.

    If you don't care if your fellow countrymen get cancer, I guess I shouldn't either.
    Man! You have GOT to try a hit of this RANGE SUNSHINE!

    IMTBO = In My Thoroughly Biased Opinion
    CMIIW = Correct Me If I'm Wrong
    Never underestimate the amount of contempt a failed musician has for those of us who are still trying.
    If the party's good enough, you can actually suck to a remarkable degree.

    Greedle
  15. #15
    Join Date Sep 2007
    Location East Glenbeckistan
    Posts 3,790
    Rep Power 536871124

    Default Re: What legislation would bring online piracy to an end?

    Just be aware that he's as biased and agenda-ridden as Mike Masnick (Techdirt),
    True.....

    but in the opposite direction.
    Like that's a bad thing?
    "Far too many people suffer from the anal-cranial inversion. They got their heads stuck up their asses!" - Tom Dowd
    "A great, timeless album is more than just an entertainment app." - Don Was
    "Success does not mean success. You are only as successful as your last hit record." - Patrick Adams (record producer)
    "The tech sector is like a guy in a crowded prison cell, who finds a hand grenade, and sets it off, so that he'll have the entire cell to himself." - Dwoz
  16. #16
    Plays in Winger cover band Born To Be Mild!
    Join Date Jul 2011
    Location Wellington NZ
    Posts 720
    Rep Power 469762099

    Default Re: What legislation would bring online piracy to an end?

    That's the only example cited in that article, if you've read it. ...
    I've read it. I've also been keeping up with the TPPA issues, which it appears you haven't. Would you like some links?
  17. #17
    Plays in Winger cover band Born To Be Mild!
    Join Date Jul 2011
    Location Wellington NZ
    Posts 720
    Rep Power 469762099

    Default Re: What legislation would bring online piracy to an end?

    True.....



    Like that's a bad thing?

    It depends on your own position. I find them both equally teeth-grinding.
  18. #18
    Join Date Nov 2006
    Location Long Island, NY, USA
    Posts 9,900
    Rep Power 536871339

    Default Re: What legislation would bring online piracy to an end?

    I've read it. I've also been keeping up with the TPPA issues, which it appears you haven't. Would you like some links?
    Only if they're relevant to the issue of piracy. Tobacco and medicine are OT.
    Man! You have GOT to try a hit of this RANGE SUNSHINE!

    IMTBO = In My Thoroughly Biased Opinion
    CMIIW = Correct Me If I'm Wrong
    Never underestimate the amount of contempt a failed musician has for those of us who are still trying.
    If the party's good enough, you can actually suck to a remarkable degree.

    Greedle
  19. #19
  20. #20
    Join Date Nov 2006
    Location Long Island, NY, USA
    Posts 9,900
    Rep Power 536871339

    Default Re: What legislation would bring online piracy to an end?

    The very first link you posted has something patently wrong, right off the bat.

    Overall, the USTR proposal for the TPP intellectual property chapter would:

    Include a number of features that would lock-in as a global norm many controversial features of U.S. law, such as endless copyright terms.
    What endless copyright terms?
    Man! You have GOT to try a hit of this RANGE SUNSHINE!

    IMTBO = In My Thoroughly Biased Opinion
    CMIIW = Correct Me If I'm Wrong
    Never underestimate the amount of contempt a failed musician has for those of us who are still trying.
    If the party's good enough, you can actually suck to a remarkable degree.

    Greedle

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts